Ultimate Enduro Bike Showdown | SC Nomad 3 | YT Capra | SC Bronson 2 | Evil Insurgent

January 31, 2016 MTB Enthusiasts of Utah

     This year I was grateful for the opportunity to own four of the most talked about and ridiculously specced Endur-bro bikes in the industry.    Sure has been an incredible year shredding the trails throughout Utah enjoying each one!   To pay homage to all those who’ve asked for reviews and the MTB community in general I thought I’d give you all the low down on how each sled compares.

     Before diving in too deep, you’ll notice each build was pretty top shelf with only subtle differences in components.  Parts from ENVE Composites, SRAM, All Mountain Style, ERGON Bike, DeityRaceface, HubsessedFoxEastForkBikesBackcountry.com Rockshox, DerbyIndustry Nine, DtSwiss, Onyx, Chris King, Maxxis & Schwalbe, will be found spread fairly evenly through each bike-a mix of components that I’ve been extremely happy with.  Enjoy!

Introducing The Steeds in no Particular Order:

IMG_6625

Evil Insurgent

FullSizeRender 11

YT Capra

IMG_4501

Santa Cruz Bronson 2

FullSizeRender 12

Santa Cruz Nomad 3

By The Numbers:

It’s completely natural to want to get nerdy and compare numbers when considering bikes and it can certainly be informative.  I don’t think I ever realized just how dramatic a millimeter here and a degree there can change things up.   Guarantee you if you show any average joe that chart they’ll laugh and say they’re pretty much the same bike – wrong!

Screen Shot 2016-01-30 at 11.26.25 PM

Takeaway number 1: size ‘Large’ is not created equal.    For example the Large Bronson 2 felt quite a bit larger than the Nomad, while the Capra felt the smallest and the Insurgent is no question the largest in the squad.  That said, all of these bikes fit me and I’m ~5’10” — so they’re all in the same ballpark.

I found a few things were really game changers when it came to the numbers.   The wheelbase is a real kicker, both the Nomad & Insurgent are easily the strongest straight line chargers and what do you know, both have the most stretched out wheelbase. The chain-stay is another element where I noticed significant differences.   While the Insurgent feels like a monster truck in the chunk, it sure is fun, playful in corners and manuals with the best of them.   The YT also shined here.  What do you know – both the shortest chain-stays.   Braap!  To be fair, the Bronson 2 was pretty poppy and fun as well.

Climbing:

A question I hear often is, “Which one climb’s better, bro?”  It’s an easy answer: The Capra.  The day I got the Capra I still had mismatched orange ENVE decals, but honey badger doesn’t give a…, I wanted to shred on it.  Bad.   I woke up a

IMG_3042

YT Capra Maiden Voyage, Top of Puke Hill, Utah

t 4am the next morning and shuttled up the Wasatch Crest Trail so I could be to work by 8, which is utter desperation and quite possibly the best morning I could personally ask for.    I couldn’t believe how well it climbed up Puke Hill.    The Capra charges climbs – I’m a Strava-tard and beat my best time on the Nomad by over a minute.   Not bad!  Not only does it charge, it is just a comfortable climber as well.

Going back to the number game for a moment, you’ll notice the seat tube angle on the Capra is a whole degree steeper than the next steed, coincidence it’s the stronger climber?  I think not.   The Bronson was interesting uphill, it was the lightest bike in the lineup and I’d argue the best suited geometry for climbing, just under 28lbs with pedals, but when it came to steep sketchy climbs it wallowed and that bothered me.  Even with that I’d still put it in the second position to the Capra when it comes to climbing.  The Insurgent and Nomad are what they are, gravity defying, face melting beasts that prefer descending to climbing, but still get the job done.   I was worried about the Insurgent.  It’s 71.9 degree seat tube angle had me questioning what I had done because I do climb quite a bit, but I was pleasantly surprised with how it performed. I’d put the Insurgent & Nomad as a pretty even wash when it comes to climbing.

Downhill

This is going to be a challenge.    All of these bikes will have you grinning from ear-to-ear on any descent, but this is a comparison so here I go making some tough choices.  If you are a numbers guy or gal you’d probably tell me the Insurgent or Nomad is the best descender of the bunch and you would be absolutely… right.   But which one is better?

The Nomad was fun and in certain situations, straight line, technical and steeps, it was just bombproof and would charge any line.  I felt so comfortable on it and looking back definitely miss the confidence inspiring feeling it gave.   Where I would say I was less than enthusedIMG_2035 was that plush feeling you’d hope for in 165mm of rear travel.   It came specced with the Rockshox Monarch Debonair, which I felt was harsh and pretty quickly jumped to the Fox Float X.   That got me by, but until I sprung for the Float X2 I wasn’t completely satisfied.    The Float X2 is a modern marvel and brought that Nomad to life.  Such an incredible piece of machinery.

Hear me out when I tell you that the Insurgent has a leg up when it comes to DH.   Maybe its Dave Weagle’s Delta Suspension System or maybe it’s the perfect balance of wheelbase, headtube angle combined with a rather short chain-stay length that makes this such a fun yet completely insane descender.  Regardles, this is a very forward thinking setup and I couldn’t be more thrilled with how well this charges in the chunk, but still pops off drops, jumps, berms and owns the ridiculously steep tech terrain that you will find peppered throughout Utah.  I was more comfortable in the rocky steep terrain on the Insurgent than I am right now on my couch with a warm fire burning.   What a bike! IMG_6679

I can’t overlook the Capra.   It’s a serious good time.   If you asked me to decide between the Nomad & Capra as the better descender I
will only say the Nomad due to the utter speed and confidence the Nomad gives in any terrain, but is utter speed what you want in every situation?   The Capra offered a balance between face melting DH and that fun park bike that you can whip through corners and have an incredible time in any situation.   I miss that goat pretty often I must say – incredible bike!

The Bronson 2 was not bad at all.    Maybe it was because it was the lightest of the four bikes or ‘steep’ 66 degree head angle, but when it came to steep tecIMG_5420 4h stuff I found myself longing for the Capra or Nomad.   I also noticed on flat peddaly sections that I often felt an odd lag and found I was peddling harder than I would have on the other sleds.   That said, the Bronson was a blast, especially when it came to small kickers and features, it was extremely poppy and playful.

Quality Control:

If you’re a perfectionist like myself you will tend to notice any design flaws the second you take the bike off the showroom floor or unbox it.    The sure winner when it comes to quality has got to be both Santa Cruz bikes.    I chose the CC model in both the Nomad 3 and Bronson 2 and could not be more happy with the finish quality of each one.   The finish was impeccable and I think you’d have a challenging time finding any bike of better craftsmanship – the attention to detail is unparalleled.

The Capra is certainly a beautiful frame – both engineering and geometry are truly incredible.    The second I unboxed it I have to say I noticed some inconsistency in the carbon, almost a ripple through some of the top tube.  I wish I had a picture to show it.  Granted, this is all external and completely superficial stuff to nit pick on, but when you’re dropping hard earned coin on a frame it’s something I personally consider.   Not only that, but it was definitely the easiest to chip paint, nor did it come with a chain-stay guard like the Evil & both Santa Cruz bikes so gracefully do.

I have to say the Insurgent’s quality is amazing.   After owning the Capra you can guarantee I inspected it and found nothing but sheer perfection.   The Delta System is ridiculous and such an incredible Engineering feat that puts this near the top of my list when it comes to quality.   The only things that truly bothered me, although superficial, the logo’s are vinyl.    Again, nit picking, but seriously, vinyl?  This is one of the more expensive frames of the bunch, paint it for goodness sakes.  Outside of the vinyl, the chain rides wildly close to the chain-stay’s, but the rubber wrapped around them make up for it.   It’s a tad loud with the chain slapping the stays, but whatever.

The Bottom Line

No doubt all four bikes are certainly a home run and should make any owner proud.   If you’re anything like me and don’t mind the grind to the top for the payoff of a rowdy good DH session then I’d spring for the Insurgent or Nomad.  My personal preference – I’ll take the best DH capable machine over climbing capability all day long.   The Capra will do both extremely well and I’d argue is the most well rounded in most any situation, the only thing that worried me was the warranty and lack of support locally.    Although the Quality was that of rich mahogany with the Bronson 2, because the wandering climbs and puckering moments on DH sections I’d call it the caboose in this comparison.

Overall I’m very happy with the bike choices I made this year and am incredibly impressed with the direction the industry is headed.   Looking forward for only good things to come!  Shred on.

Review by: MTB Enthusiasts of Utah:  Instagram | Facebook

Would love to interact in comments below!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

MTB Enthusiasts of Utah

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mtbenthusiastsofutah/

Comments (23)

  1. theminsta

    1. Capra
    2. Insurgent
    3. Nomad
    4. Bromad?

    Twas a good read LB. I wish you had the SB6c and Patrol to test as well!

    • MTB Enthusiasts of Utah

      Thanks man.

      Tough call. I’d say Capra / Insurgent, Nomad, Bronson. Capra & Insurgent are incredible and both at the top for different reasons.

      I am with you on the SB6c and Patrol. High on my list of bikes, one day my friend.

  2. Did you have all of the bikes at the same time? Just curious on whether you were able to switch back and forth or rode them in sequence. Great review of a lot of top bikes.

    • MTB Enthusiasts of Utah

      Hey good question! I did not have all bikes at the same time, they were all ridden within a 12 month time period.

      Thanks!

  3. Brian

    Will you please talk more about the pros and cons of the Insurgent vs Capra? Trying to decide between them and unable to find a demo for either. Thanks alot!

  4. Andrew

    Good read I’d highly recommend throwing a leg over the Guerrilla Gravity Megatrail. The bike is a beast and climbs great!

    • MTB Enthusiasts of Utah

      Thank you for the Data! That explains why the climbing is much better than I had thought.

      They recently updated the geo after Bible of Bikes.

      I’ll get it changed.

      By the way, my game is Landon 🙂

  5. Alex

    Do you find that the evil was a little too big for you since your height is 5 10″?

    • MTB Enthusiasts of Utah

      Not at all. It feels perfect! I do have long arms so I get comments pretty often asking if large bikes are too big, but my monkey arms require a Lrg bike.

  6. Alex

    same as me but I am only 5 6″ or 168cm so looking at M size. Thank you

  7. gbcoke

    great review though i didn’t understand which bike you currently own/picked (sorry if i missed it) ? also, the Insurgent value is pretty high at around 5200 for an x1/pike rct/raceface-easton componets,dont you think ? from what ive seen the only better value bikes are from purely direct sell brands.it is something that seems to be overlooked on allot of Evil reviews for some reason (even the frame cost of 2799 usd with an headset,chain guide and monarch+ is pretty competitive IMHO).

  8. Alberto

    Thanks for those reviews really helpful. I would love to see the new intense uzzi 275 with a Float X2 in this showdown…

  9. Wes Cassells

    What setting did you use on the Capra Fox X2?

    Vol spacers
    Sag %
    LSC
    HSC
    LSR
    HSR

    Thanks

    • MTB Enthusiasts of Utah

      Thanks for your question. I was running the Monarch on the Capra.

  10. gavin

    hi there whats better transition patrol or yt capra I hear capra crack head tubes

  11. Luke Petersen

    Good review, not often I see all the bikes I would like to buy being reviewed by one rider in one place. Clearly there’s a bike in there for every rider but for me it’s the Capra. Good price, good ascender and a good descender, what more could you ask for? Finish quality is the only black mark but all my bikes end up looking like they’ve been through a cheese grater including my current Santa Claus 🙂

  12. Alex

    Hi mate!
    Great reviews. I own the current Bronson xo1 and was curious what pressure/sag were u running with the Fox evoL. SC recommends 15-17mm sag.
    For anyone looking at the Bro, I’ll add to keep in mind that adjusting the rebound on the shock is a nightmare due to the upper link being in the way. But needless to say the bike is a massive improvement over the first version.
    Cheers

  13. Bhill

    Great writing Landon… No wonder you rode all the bikes.. Great way to get the on trail review. Loved it.

  14. Diego

    Landon,

    Really helpful, thanks!
    I am 5 6″ or 168cm, what Capra size would you recommend?

    Thanks in advance.
    Diego

Comments are closed.

Shopping cart

Subtotal
Shipping and discount codes are added at checkout.
Checkout